Old Fashioned Chess Pie (Classic Southern Recipe)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

This Old Fashioned Chess Pie is more than just a dessert; it's a piece of family history. This recipe is an adaptation of the one handed down to my Mother-in-Law from her mother, who lived in rural Oklahoma during the 1930s Dust Bowl and the Great Depression.

They actually lived through the hardships described in John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath. At that time, ingredients were very limited, and families had to make do with what they had in the pantry.

However, for special occasions, they would bake this simple, sweet Chess Pie. It became one of my Mother-in-Law’s favorite childhood memories, and today, I am honored to share this authentic slice of history with you.

Table of Contents

• Why You’ll Love This Recipe
• Why is it called Chess Pie?
• What is the Difference Between Chess Pie and Buttermilk Pie?
• What Do I Need To Make Chess Pie
• How To Make Chess Pie
• How Long To Bake Chess Pie
• Cooling The Chess Pie
• How To Store Leftover Chess Pie
• Pro Recipe Tips
• Variations of Chess Pie
• What To Serve With Chess Pie
• Why Is Chess Pie So Sweet?
• More Southern Pie Recipes
• Recipe
• Reviews

What Do I Need To Make Chess Pie

Equipment

Below are tools to use to make this recipe. If you click on the affiliate links below, you can view the product on Amazon.com. If you choose to purchase the item from Amazon.com, I will receive a very small commission at no additional cost to you.

• Stand Mixer – I like this KitchenAid model Stand Mixer. If you don’t have a stand mixer, use a hand mixer  or whisk and large mixing bowl.
• Pie Plate

Ingredients And Substitutions

Below are the ingredients needed, as well as a few substitutions, to make Old Fashioned Chess Pie. For specific amounts of each ingredient, scroll down to the bottom of this article, just above the comments, for the complete printable recipe card.

• One 9-inch refrigerated pie crust – or a homemade pie crust.
• Butter. You will need 1 stick of butter. Either salted or unsalted butter will work.
• Granulated sugar. You will need between 1 cup to 2 cups of sugar. I give a range because chess pie is extremely sweet. Some people may think it is too sweet. If you have never tried Chess pie before, you may want to start with 1 cup of sugar and see if that is sweet enough for you. If not, you can always add more sugar but you can’t take it away.
• 4 eggs. Yes, that number of eggs is correct. It is a very rich custard pie.
• Vanilla. I recommend using pure vanilla and not imitation vanilla. If you use imitation vanilla then you may only want to use 1/2 teaspoon instead of 1 teaspoon.
• Cornmeal. You will need 1 – 2 tablespoons of cornmeal. Yes, this pie has cornmeal in it. While the pie cooks, the cornmeal rises to the top to create a thin crust.
• Salt.
• Milk. I recommend using whole milk or buttermilk. I don’t recommend using low fat milk or skim milk.
• White vinegar. You will need just 1 tablespoon white vinegar. If you don’t have white vinegar, you could use lemon juice instead.
• Ingredient Amounts. Once again, if you are looking for the list of ingredients with the specific amounts of each listed, scroll down to the bottom of this article, just above the comments, for the printable recipe card.

How To Make Chess Pie

Below are high level instructions for the major steps of How to Make Chess Pie. However, for more detailed instructions with specific ingredient amounts, scroll down to the bottom of the article, just above the comments, for the printable recipe card.

1. Start out beating butter and sugar in a stand mixer or with a hand mixer and mixing bowl.
2. Add eggs, vanilla, cornmeal, milk, vinegar, and salt and mix until smooth.
3. Pour into a prepared 9-inch pie shell.
4. For more specific instructions, scroll down to the bottom of the article, just above the comments, to the printable recipe card.

How Long To Bake Chess Pie

Bake in a preheated oven at 325 degrees F for about 60 – 65 minutes.  Watch the edges of the pie crust to make sure that they don’t brown too quickly. If needed, shield the edges of the pie crust by covering them with strips of aluminum foil.

Cooling The Chess Pie

Let the Chess Pie cool for about 1 hour at room temperature before serving.

How To Store Leftover Chess Pie

Cover the pie and refrigerate it until you are ready to serve again. 

Pro Recipe Tips

• Sugar. Traditional Chess Pie is a very sweet pie. Start with 1 cup of sugar and if you need to add more, add 1/4 cup at a time to see if it meets your desired level of sweetness. The old recipe originally called for 2 cups of sugar but my family and I found that it made the pie much too sweet for us.
• Room Temperature. Start with eggs and butter at room temperature. This will soften the butter and ensure a better filling.
• Vanilla. Use pure vanilla and not imitation vanilla. It does make a difference. If you still decide to use imitation vanilla, then I recommend reducing the amount of vanilla to 1/2 teaspoons because imitation vanilla tends to be stronger than pure vanilla.
• Shield Edges of Pie Crust. If the edges of the pie crust start to brown too fast, cover them with thin strips of foil to prevent them from overcooking.
• Cooling. Don’t serve the Chess Pie immediately out of the oven. Instead, let it cool on a wire rack for about an hour, and then refrigerate the pie after that until ready to serve.

Variations of Chess Pie

• Chocolate Chess Pie – Add 4 tablespoons cocoa powder to the pie filling.
• Lemon Chess Pie – Add 1/4 cup lemon juice to the pie filling.
• Coconut Chess Pie – Add 1 cup of flaked coconut to the pie filling.
• Eggnog Chess Pie – Replace whole milk and vinegar with 1/3 cup eggnog.

What To Serve With Chess Pie

Make an entire meal by serving Old Fashioned Chess Pie as a dessert to go with these other Southern dishes.

• Instant Pot Smothered Pork Chops
• Instant Pot Pulled Pork
• Instant Pot Chicken And Dumplings
• Apple Walnut Cranberry Salad
• Roasted Brussels Sprouts With Bacon and Balsamic
• Cheesy Bacon Ranch Hash Brown Casserole

Why Is Chess Pie So Sweet?

One of the reasons Chess Pie is so sweet is that hundreds of years ago, people would add sugar to milk and unsalted butter to keep them from going bad. This pie originally had 2 cups of sugar. Since that was overly sweet to us today and we don’t need to use the sugar as a preservative, I have cut back on the sugar in the recipe by 1/2 cup. It remains still very sweet but not overly sweet. Be sure to read my notes below about recommendations on adding the sugar.

More Southern Pie Recipes

• Crustless Pumpkin Pie – This pumpkin piekeeps only the best part of the pumpkin pie, the pumpkin pie filling, and is so delicious that you won't miss the crust.
• German Chocolate Pecan Pie – This German Chocolate Pecan Pie combines German Chocolate Cake and Pecan Pie into one fabulous holiday dessert!
• No Bake Banana Pudding Cream Pie – This easy No Bake Banana Pudding Cream Pie recipe is super easy to make and requires no baking!

If you like this recipe or make this recipe,  be sure to leave a comment, rate the recipe, and follow us on:

Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Instagram

Recipe